Gemstone Wholesale Prices and the Art of Appraising

Although a list of gemstone wholesale prices can be a valuable tool for determining a gemstone's value, an accurate appraisal requires extensive knowledge and experience on the part of the appraiser. “Emeralds and White Gold” by Mauro Cateb by CC by 2.0
Although a list of gemstone wholesale prices can be a valuable tool for determining a gemstone’s value, an accurate appraisal requires extensive knowledge and experience on the part of the appraiser. “Emeralds and White Gold” by Mauro Cateb by CC by 2.0

Question

I’m having some emerald gemstones appraised by a Master Gemologist. Since I’m looking at selling the items I’m dealing in wholesale, do you know where I can find a list of gemstone wholesale prices? I want to familiarize myself with the possible values of any stones I acquire down the line. I’m not planning to use this information to set a higher price on the gems I trade. I’m relying on the appraiser to determine the true gemstone wholesale prices. I just want to learn more about wholesale values, because that’s what I plan to be involved in.

Thanks again for any help you can give me.

Betsy Anselp

Answer

There are a few guides for gemstone wholesale prices available. Most are expensive and limited to a few gems. The International Gem Society’s gem price guide is based on some of the best sources to make it as broad and inclusive as possible. I know it’s difficult to find a value with such a broad range, but that’s an accurate reflection of today’s market.

You should understand, however, that appraising gemstones is an art. It’s not something that can be taught or completed just with pricing formulas. A guide for gemstone wholesale prices is just one element used for appraisals. Knowledge and experience are other critical elements.

The only good appraisers I know are either gem wholesalers or full-time appraisers. You need to understand all the subtleties of gemstone grading and pricing to do an accurate job. A subtle change in grade can often make a significant change in value. It takes a lot of experience (and maybe a set of master stones) to distinguish between the top color grades of emerald, ruby, etc. Reading or viewing pictures cannot teach this.

Now, let’s simplify matters. You don’t need an extensive background to find gems that you can sell for a profit. As you gain more experience, your ability to find stones that you can buy below retail will also improve. The market abounds with these deals. It sounds like you’re already off to a good start.

Sincerely,

Donald Clark, CSM IMG

“5-carat Ruby Engagement/Wedding Ring” by 3BL Media is licensed under CC By 2.0
“5-carat Ruby Engagement/Wedding Ring” by 3BL Media is licensed under CC By 2.0