How To Evaluate Diamond Symmetry

solitary ring and round diamond - diamond symmetry
“Solitary Ring and Diamond,” 18K white gold and a 1-ct brilliant-cut diamond, before setting, by Mauro Cateb. Licensed under CC By-SA 4.0.

Gemologists must often evaluate diamond symmetry. For a rigorous evaluation, you’ll need a proportion scope. This device lets you project the image of the diamond onto a screen to measure lengths and angles. Unfortunately, this device has two drawbacks. First, it’s designed primarily for evaluating loose stones. Second, it’s quite expensive.

As a result, many gemology students try to evaluate the symmetry of a set diamond without a proportion scope. They’ll take a risk and do a visual and imprecise “loupe and eye” evaluation.

An Inexpensive Alternative to a Proportion Scope

During the 1970s, Dr. Kazumi Okuda solved these problems. He utilized a 10X magnifying glass and a reflector of colored plastic (red, reddish, or orange color). This idea is based on a simple principle, illustrated in Figure 1.

Figure 1 - diamond symmetry
Figure 1.

The interior of the plastic reflector reflects light from a lamp to the diamond. The gem reflects that light, now red or reddish, with either a perfect or imperfect shape, depending on the diamond’s cut and proportions.

If the diamond is perfect, the observed image will be identical to Figure 2.

figure 2 - diamond symmetry
Figure 2.

If the plastic reflector is red, the red zones mean a perfect return of the light. The white zones indicate a leak of the light, which means a flaw in the proportions. The triangular black forms allow you to evaluate the symmetry. A pink (not red) color indicates a partial return of the light, which means a minor flaw in the symmetry. Observe the flaws in Figure 3.

figure 3 - diamond symmetry
Figure 3.

You should classify the example above as “Poor,” assuming symmetry categories of “Excellent,” “Very Good,” “Good,” “Fair,” and “Poor.”

The position of the light depends on whether the diamond is loose or mounted. If loose, orient the light directly behind it. If mounted, use incandescent light coming from above (as in Figure 1), reflected, never direct, by a piece of white paper. With some practice, an aspiring gemologist can determine the optimal type of illumination.

A Do-It-Yourself Way to Measure Diamond Symmetry

If you have a triplet lens laying about unused, you can build one of these tools easily. For a reflector, choose a tubular piece of any red plastic with a flat interior surface that reflects light well. (I successfully used a red cover of WD-40 lubricant. See Figure 4). The ideal material shouldn’t be totally opaque. Your tubular piece can have a constant diameter or an enlarged one like a funnel. The only assembly to be done is uniting the piece of plastic to the lens. Remember that cyanoacrylate glues don’t mix with optic parts.

figure 4 - diamond symmetry
Figure 4.

For the area between the lenses and the cover, use any cylindrical piece of material on hand. (Alternatively, you could ask a machinist to create an aluminum cylinder). In the closed part of the cover, cleanly cut a circular hole 6 mm in diameter exactly at the center. This size diameter will allow you to fully see diamonds up to 1 carat. You can see how the lens and cylinder go together in Figures 5 and 6 below.

figure 5 - diamond symmetry
Figure 5.
figure 6 - diamond symmetry
Figure 6.

Remember, the opening of the red reflector should be at the focal point of the lenses. If you’re unsure about this, just focus the image from a lamp with the lens over a piece of paper. With the image at its minimum, carefully measure the distance between the lens and the paper.

For very accurate diamond symmetry measurements, you can use a filar micrometer with a goniometer. See Figure 7.

figure 7 - diamond symmetry
Figure 7.

About the author
Dr. Raul Berenguel, PhD.
Dr. Raul Berenguel, PhD. holds a degree in History (Scientific Branch) from Universidade de Aberta (2008), having obtained a PhD in Contemporary Art (2012), in the specialty of Contemporary Art (specifically in Gemology), at the same university. He has specific expertise in history, gemology and contemporary art, and the application of the traditional technical means of gemology in the gemological investigation applied to objects of art.
All articles by this author